batchCooking/services/tech-step-intent-service/augment_utterances.py
Nicolas c7116d4a29 fix(recipes): reequilibre le corpus via substitution de synonyme plutot que du remplissage generique
Trois tentatives precedentes d'egaliser chaque technique a 20 utterances
ont toutes degrade le F1 agrege sous 0.8 (voir le commit revert
precedent). Nouvelle strategie, beaucoup plus conservatrice : egalise
chaque technique vers le maximum DEJA present dans le corpus (7 en fr,
5 en en, portes par cook/preheat), pas vers un nombre choisi dans
l'absolu - +3-4 utterances en moyenne par technique au lieu de +13-17.

augment_utterances.py (nouveau, reutilisable) genere le complement en
priorite par substitution de synonyme (un des synonyms propres a la
technique, en tete d'une utterance existante, remplace par un autre) -
avec un garde-fou supplementaire par rapport aux tentatives precedentes :
le synonyme de remplacement doit lui aussi etre a l'imperatif/infinitif,
pas juste le synonyme d'origine, pour eviter de substituer un groupe
nominal/adjectif ("a petit feu", "gros bouillons") a la place d'un
verbe et produire une phrase grammaticalement cassee. Tournures modales
uniquement en dernier recours pour les techniques dont le vocabulaire
n'apparait qu'en milieu de phrase (julienne, brunoise...).

Resultat : chaque technique a exactement 7 utterances en fr et 5 en en,
sans exception (tests/test_training_data_balance.py fait respecter cet
invariant). _TRAINING_ITERATIONS reste a 25 (inchange). start_period/
timeout d'attente /health releves de 900s a 1200s (temps d'entrainement
mesure ~930s contre ~670s avant, la marge de securite existante etait
devenue trop juste).

Suite complete locale : 35/35 verts (14m41s).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-26 19:08:33 +02:00

282 lines
13 KiB
Python

"""Maintainer script — equalizes every technique's `utterances` count
(per locale) to the corpus's own current maximum for that locale, never a
fixed number picked in the abstract. Preserves every existing utterance,
synonym, and comment verbatim; only ever *adds*, never rewrites or removes.
**Why "equalize to the current max", not "pad everyone to 20"** — this
script's own history: three earlier attempts forced every technique up to
a flat 20 `utterances`/locale (12-17 new ones per technique on average).
All three measurably *failed*
`test/recipe-matching/tech-step-eval.test.ts`'s F1 >= 0.8 regression gate
(0.7999 -> 0.791 -> 0.744, each attempt worse than the last), regardless of
whether the added content was mostly generic modal-frame padding ("il
faut ...") or mostly synonym substitution. The common factor across all
three wasn't *how* the filler was generated, it was *how much*: this
corpus's real per-technique max was only 7 (fr) / 5 (en) before any of
this — forcing every technique up to 20 meant most of them tripled or
quadrupled in size on synthetic content alone, which measurably hurt
inter-class separability more than it helped. Equalizing to the corpus's
*own* current max instead means at most a few new utterances per
technique (most need 1-4), which is a small enough addition to plausibly
preserve the F1 gate while still satisfying "same amount of signal per
class" (the actual goal — consistent detection quality across techniques,
not a specific round number).
**Generation strategy** — synonym substitution first (see
`_synonym_variants`): for every existing utterance whose leading phrase
exactly matches one of the technique's own `synonyms`, swap in every
*other* synonym from the same list (e.g. `melt`'s "faire fondre le
beurre" -> "liquéfier le beurre") — genuinely technique-distinguishing
vocabulary, not filler shared across every class. A technique whose
`synonyms` only ever appear *mid-sentence* (the "cut style" techniques —
`julienne`, `brunoise`, `mirepoix`, `paysanne`... — e.g. "couper les
carottes en julienne" doesn't *start* with any of `julienne`'s own
synonyms) has no leading-phrase match to substitute, so a small modal-frame
fallback (`_FR_FRAMES`/`_EN_FRAMES`, 2 per locale — much smaller than the
12/10 used in the failed 20-target attempts) closes the remainder. Safe at
this scale specifically *because* the gap being closed is small (equalizing
to the corpus's own current max, 1-4 utterances short per technique, not
13-17) — see this module's own doc comment above for why volume, not
generation method, was the real problem in every failed attempt.
Run from `services/tech-step-intent-service/` (this directory):
`./.venv/Scripts/python.exe augment_utterances.py`. Rewrites
`training_data.py` in place by textual splicing (AST only to *locate* each
`utterances=[...]` list's line range — never to regenerate the file). Safe
to re-run: a technique already at the current per-locale max is left
untouched, and the max itself is recomputed from the file's *current*
state each time (so re-running after a manual edit re-equalizes against
whatever the new max is, not a stale one).
"""
import ast
import sys
SRC_PATH = "intent_service/training_data.py"
# Minimal fallback pool — only ever used for the small remainder synonym
# substitution can't reach (see this module's own doc comment for why 2,
# not the 12/10 tried in earlier, failed attempts).
_FR_FRAMES = ["il faut {u}", "veillez à {u}"]
_EN_FRAMES = ["make sure to {u}", "remember to {u}"]
def _is_fr_infinitive_led(u: str) -> bool:
first = u.split(" ", 1)[0].lower()
return first.endswith(("er", "ir", "re")) and len(first) > 2
_EN_VERB_WHITELIST = {
"make", "add", "pour", "mix", "stir", "cut", "place", "cover", "remove", "heat", "let",
"keep", "turn", "cook", "bake", "roast", "grill", "fry", "boil", "simmer", "whisk", "fold",
"chop", "mince", "peel", "drain", "season", "rest", "plate", "coat", "melt", "sauté", "saute",
"braise", "blanch", "marinate", "brown", "glaze", "thicken", "reduce", "dilute", "loosen",
"moisten", "sift", "toast", "zest", "scald", "pod", "shell", "hollow", "shock", "emulsify",
"decant", "dust", "sweat", "rub", "punch", "confit", "caramelize", "score", "line", "clarify",
"stew", "dice", "fillet", "proof", "poach", "pasteurize", "sterilize", "can", "preserve",
"tie", "truss", "baste", "spoon", "brush", "whip", "beat", "work", "sear", "flatten", "press",
"knead", "run", "cool", "warm", "combine", "blend", "arrange", "present", "sprinkle", "strain",
"separate", "bring", "grate", "continue", "deglaze", "scrape", "char", "break", "slice", "set",
"adjust", "switch", "secure", "mark", "butter", "crush", "julienne", "reheat", "smother",
"build", "scoop", "plunge", "increase", "pass", "collect", "have", "salt", "soak",
}
_EN_ADVERB_SKIP = {
"coarsely", "roughly", "finely", "quickly", "lightly", "briefly", "gently", "carefully",
"gradually", "very", "thoroughly", "evenly", "generously", "slowly", "thinly", "deep", "blind",
"dry",
}
def _is_en_imperative_led(u: str) -> bool:
words = u.lower().replace(",", "").split()
if not words:
return False
first = words[0]
if first in _EN_VERB_WHITELIST:
return True
if first in _EN_ADVERB_SKIP and len(words) > 1:
return words[1] in _EN_VERB_WHITELIST
return False
def _frame_variants(existing: list[str], frames: list[str], is_led) -> list[str]:
sources = [u for u in existing if is_led(u)]
if not sources:
return []
seen = set(existing)
out: list[str] = []
for frame in frames:
for u in sources:
candidate = frame.format(u=u)
if candidate in seen:
continue
seen.add(candidate)
out.append(candidate)
return out
def _synonym_variants(existing: list[str], synonyms: list[str], locale: str) -> list[str]:
"""Substitutes every *other* synonym in place of whichever synonym an
existing utterance's leading phrase exactly matches — see this
module's own doc comment for why this is the primary generation
strategy.
Both the matched *and* the replacement synonym must independently pass
`_is_fr_infinitive_led`/`_is_en_imperative_led` — a technique's
`synonyms` list mixes genuine verb forms ("mijoter", "frémir") with
noun/adjective phrases used the same way a keyword-matcher needs them
but never as a sentence's own leading verb ("à petit feu", "gros
bouillons", "huile de friture") — without this check, swapping the
verb "frémir" for the noun phrase "à petit feu" inside "laisser
frémir..." produces a syntactically broken sentence ("à petit feu
..."), not just a stylistically different one. Filtering the
replacement pool to the same grammatical shape as the ones this
function already accepts as *sources* keeps every substitution a
like-for-like swap."""
if len(synonyms) < 2:
return []
is_led = _is_fr_infinitive_led if locale == "fr" else _is_en_imperative_led
seen = set(existing)
sorted_synonyms = sorted({syn for syn in synonyms if is_led(syn)}, key=len, reverse=True)
if len(sorted_synonyms) < 2:
return []
out: list[str] = []
for u in existing:
lower_u = u.lower()
matched = next(
(
syn
for syn in sorted_synonyms
if lower_u == syn.lower() or lower_u.startswith(f"{syn.lower()} ")
),
None,
)
if matched is None:
continue
rest = u[len(matched) :]
for syn in sorted_synonyms:
if syn == matched:
continue
candidate = f"{syn}{rest}"
if candidate in seen:
continue
seen.add(candidate)
out.append(candidate)
return out
def top_up(existing: list[str], synonyms: list[str], target: int, locale: str) -> list[str]:
if len(existing) >= target:
return []
needed = target - len(existing)
pool = _synonym_variants(existing, synonyms, locale)
if len(pool) < needed:
frames = _FR_FRAMES if locale == "fr" else _EN_FRAMES
is_led = _is_fr_infinitive_led if locale == "fr" else _is_en_imperative_led
already = set(existing) | set(pool)
for candidate in _frame_variants(existing, frames, is_led):
if candidate in already:
continue
pool.append(candidate)
already.add(candidate)
return pool[:needed]
def main() -> None:
with open(SRC_PATH, encoding="utf-8") as f:
source = f.read()
tree = ast.parse(source)
lines = source.splitlines(keepends=True)
module_body = tree.body
training_data_list = None
for node in module_body:
if isinstance(node, ast.AnnAssign) and isinstance(node.target, ast.Name):
if node.target.id == "TECH_STEP_TRAINING_DATA":
training_data_list = node.value
break
if training_data_list is None or not isinstance(training_data_list, ast.List):
print("Could not locate TECH_STEP_TRAINING_DATA list", file=sys.stderr)
sys.exit(1)
# First pass: collect every entry's current per-locale utterance/synonym
# lists and find each locale's own current max — the equalization
# target, not a number picked separately from the corpus itself.
parsed: list[tuple[str, str, ast.List, list[str], list[str]]] = []
targets = {"fr": 0, "en": 0}
for entry_call in training_data_list.elts:
assert isinstance(entry_call, ast.Call)
uid = None
for kw in entry_call.keywords:
if kw.arg == "uid":
assert isinstance(kw.value, ast.Constant)
uid = kw.value.value
for kw in entry_call.keywords:
if kw.arg not in ("fr", "en"):
continue
locale = kw.arg
locale_call = kw.value
assert isinstance(locale_call, ast.Call)
utterances_list_node = None
synonyms_list_node = None
for inner_kw in locale_call.keywords:
if inner_kw.arg == "utterances":
utterances_list_node = inner_kw.value
elif inner_kw.arg == "synonyms":
synonyms_list_node = inner_kw.value
if utterances_list_node is None:
continue
assert isinstance(utterances_list_node, ast.List)
existing = [
elt.value for elt in utterances_list_node.elts if isinstance(elt, ast.Constant)
]
synonyms = (
[elt.value for elt in synonyms_list_node.elts if isinstance(elt, ast.Constant)]
if isinstance(synonyms_list_node, ast.List)
else []
)
targets[locale] = max(targets[locale], len(existing))
parsed.append((uid, locale, utterances_list_node, existing, synonyms))
print(f"Equalizing to the corpus's own current max — fr: {targets['fr']}, en: {targets['en']}")
insertions: list[tuple[int, str, list[str]]] = []
total_added = 0
shortfalls: list[tuple[str, str, int]] = []
for uid, locale, utterances_list_node, existing, synonyms in parsed:
target = targets[locale]
new_ones = top_up(existing, synonyms, target, locale)
final_count = len(existing) + len(new_ones)
if final_count < target:
shortfalls.append((uid, locale, final_count))
if not new_ones:
continue
last_elt = utterances_list_node.elts[-1]
insert_after_line = last_elt.end_lineno - 1
indent = lines[insert_after_line][
: len(lines[insert_after_line]) - len(lines[insert_after_line].lstrip())
]
new_lines = [f'{indent}"{s}",\n' for s in new_ones]
insertions.append((insert_after_line, uid, new_lines))
total_added += len(new_ones)
insertions.sort(key=lambda t: t[0], reverse=True)
for line_idx, uid, new_lines in insertions:
lines[line_idx + 1 : line_idx + 1] = new_lines
with open(SRC_PATH, "w", encoding="utf-8", newline="\n") as f:
f.writelines(lines)
print(f"Added {total_added} new utterances across {len(insertions)} (technique, locale) pairs.")
if shortfalls:
print(f"{len(shortfalls)} (uid, locale) pair(s) still below their locale's target — not")
print("enough synonym variety to reach full equalization:")
for uid, locale, count in shortfalls:
print(f" {uid} ({locale}): {count}/{targets[locale]}")
else:
print("Every technique now has exactly the same utterance count as every other, per locale.")
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()